Many in the market are rushing to judgment that the Serta decision is the final straw that will tilt the debtor’s favorite filing venue scale in favor of New Jersey. We at 9fin are skeptical — and not just because the dispute in Del Monte Foods over whether rolled-up DIP payouts must be shared with non-participating lenders is still simmering.
9fin has not been shy about calling a DNR on a venue in the past; in June 2024, we declared the Eastern District of Virginia “may be dead to debtors counsel” following the decision in Enviva to deny debtors’ choice of counsel retention due to a disclosed conflict. And not a single mega-case has been filed in the EDVA since.
The Southern District of Texas is not the Eastern District of Virginia, and Serta is not Enviva, but there is an undeniable shift within the Southern District of Texas precedent, for example, ConvergeOne and Incora, that the latest Serta decision highlights. Accordingly, the Serta decision may make other districts like the District of New Jersey even more enticing to debtors’ counsel.
Comparing Serta’s bankruptcy litigation in SDTX to that of Del Monte’s taking place in the District of New...






